)
October 2,
2010
―
The massive economic stimulus package President Obama pushed through
Congress
last year is
coming in on
time and
under budget
- and with
strikingly
few claims
of fraud or
abuse -
according to
a White
House report
to be
released
Friday.
Coming barely a month before
November's midterm elections,
which will determine whether
Democrats retain control of
Congress, the report challenges
public perceptions of the
stimulus aid as slow-moving and
wasteful - an image that has
fueled voter anger with the
dominant party. Even some former
skeptics who predicted the money
would lead to rampant abuse now
acknowledge the program could
serve as a model for improving
efficiency in government.
By the end of September, the
administration had spent 70
percent of the act's original
$787 billion, which met a White
House goal of quickly pumping
money into the nation's ravaged
economy, the report says. The
administration also met nearly a
dozen deadlines set by Congress
for getting money out the door.
Meanwhile,
lower-than-anticipated costs for
some projects have permitted the
administration to stretch
stimulus money further than
expected, financing an
additional 3,000 projects,
according to the report.
Despite the speedy spending,
the report says stimulus
contracts and grants have so far
been relatively free of the
fraud charges that plague more
routine government spending
programs. Complaints have been
filed on less than 2 percent of
awards under the program.
"Certainly, the fraud and
waste element has been smaller
than I think anything anybody
anticipated," said Steve Ellis,
vice president of Taxpayers for
Common Sense, a nonpartisan
watchdog group. "You can
certainly challenge some
projects as questionable
economically. But there haven't
been the examples of outright
fraud where the money is
essentially lining somebody's
pocket."
The report is one in a series
of assessments prepared by Vice
President Biden, who was charged
with overseeing implementation
of the stimulus money, the
largest effort in U.S. history
to counteract the effects of a
recession. The Congressional
Budget Office originally
estimated the package of tax
cuts, state aid and direct
federal spending would cost $787
billion over the next decade, a
figure that has since been
revised to $814 billion.
Biden delivered the report to
Obama on Thursday during the
president's daily economic
briefing. In addition to
assessing how the stimulus
program has been carried out,
the study restates the
administration's case the
package has been effective
economically, arguing it
staunched the worst bleeding in
employment and led the economy
to rebound late last year.
Many prominent economists
agree with that assessment. The
CBO has forecast the package may
be on track to meet the
administration's goal of
preserving 3.5 million jobs by
the end of the year.
Congressional Republicans and
many conservatives challenge
those claims, arguing the
stimulus package led to record
budget deficits while doing
little to improve the economy.
With the unemployment rate stuck
at 9.6 percent, polls show about
two-thirds of voters agree with
that view.
"The administration predicted
unemployment wouldn't rise above
8 percent if the trillion-dollar
stimulus became law. We know how
that turned out," Senate
Minority leader Mitch McConnell
(R-Ky.) said Friday.
"Unemployment, now at 9.6
percent, has hovered near double
digits since the stimulus
passed; we took on an additional
trillion dollars in debt, and
Americans' confidence in the
administration's economic
arguments never recovered."
Signed into law by Obama in
February 2009, the package was
designed to stimulate economic
activity and preserve jobs at a
time when private-sector
activity had virtually collapsed
and employers were shedding an
average of 750,000 jobs a month.
Speed was of paramount
importance, and the
administration vowed to get 70
percent of the money out the
door within 18 months.
The report shows the
administration has met that
target, spending $551 billion of
the original $787 billion. That
figure includes $242 billion in
tax breaks to families and
businesses and $232 billion in
payments to states, unemployed
workers and other victims of the
recession, the report says. The
administration has also written
$77 billion in checks for
thousands of public works
projects, with an additional
$127 billion unspent but
committed, the report says.
Meeting the 70 percent goal
"is an important
accomplishment," said Jared
Bernstein, Biden's chief
economist. "The fact the impact
of this program was quickly felt
in the economy and quickly went
to work breaking the back of the
great recession is something we
wanted to take note of."
Administration officials also
highlighted the relatively small
number of complaints about
contracts related to the
stimulus package. An independent
board established to provide
oversight has received just
3,806 complaints - less than 2
percent of more than 200,000
awards. Prosecutors have
initiated 424 criminal
investigations, representing 0.2
percent of all awards.
Typically, 5 to 7 percent of
government contracts attract
complaints, Bernstein said.
Stan Soloway, president of
the Professional Services
Council, which represents
government contractors, said the
unprecedented focus on oversight
clearly paid off and should be
analyzed for lessons that could
be applied throughout the
government.
"Given the ambitious nature
of the stimulus, the fact things
have gone relatively smoothly
suggests they did put
appropriate and adequate
resources" into program
oversight, said Soloway, an
early skeptic of the package.
"They definitely deserve credit
for that," he said.
Bernstein said "people's
feelings about the recovery act
or the role of government in
society" are unlikely to change
because of Friday's report. "We
have a ton more work left to
do," he said.
But the report serves to verify,
he said, "The recovery act has
accomplished much of what it set
out to do."