Secure Communities Tears Families Apart
WASHINGTON & SANTA
FE, NM (By Julia
Preston, NYT) August
16, 2011
A program that is
central to President
Obama’s immigration
enforcement strategy
has drawn protests
by Latino and
immigrant
organizations in six
cities in the last
two days, as those
groups stepped up
their confrontation
with the
administration over
the fast pace of
deportations.
In Los Angeles,
about 200 immigrants
and their supporters
walked out of a
stormy hearing
Monday evening that
was called by a task
force advising the
enforcement program,
known as Secure
Communities. Bearing
signs that said
“Stop Ripping
Families Apart,” the
protesters called
for an end to the
program, which they
said had led to the
deportation of
victims who reported
domestic violence to
the police, and to
parents of American
citizen children.
On Tuesday in
Chicago, several
dozen protesters
delivered thousands
of petitions calling
for an end to the
program to the
headquarters of Mr.
Obama’s re-election
campaign. Petitions
were also delivered
by small groups of
protesters to
Democratic Party
offices in Miami,
Atlanta, Houston and
Charlotte, N.C.
About two dozen
prominent immigrant
advocacy
organizations issued
a report denouncing
the program and
calling on the
administration to
halt it.
Organizers said the
protests were a
response to an
announcement on Aug.
5 by Immigration and
Customs Enforcement,
the federal agency
that runs Secure
Communities, that
the program would
continue to expand
to meet its declared
goal of covering the
whole country by
2013. Clarifying
doubts about whether
states and cities
could choose whether
to participate, John
Morton, the agency’s
director, said that
agreements with
state and local
officials were not
required for the
agency to proceed.
President Obama has
made no headway in a
divided Congress
toward an
immigration overhaul
that would give
legal status to
millions of illegal
immigrants. At the
same time, in each
of the last two
years immigration
authorities have
deported nearly
400,000 people.
Under Secure
Communities,
fingerprints of
anyone booked into
jail by the state
and local police are
sent to the F.B.I.
for criminal checks
— long a routine
practice — and also
to the Department of
Homeland Security,
which records
immigration
violations.
Immigration agents
decide whether to
detain noncitizens
signaled by
fingerprint matches.
The ferment on
Tuesday exposed
vastly differing
views of the program
between immigrant
advocates and Obama
administration
officials. In an
interview, Mr.
Morton said the
program was working
effectively to carry
out his agency’s
focus on deporting
immigrants convicted
of serious crimes.
“It’s the law, and
we think it is very
good policy, to
focus our resources
on people who are
here unlawfully and
also committing
crimes,” Mr. Morton
said.
He said agency
figures showed that
about 90 percent of
those deported under
Secure Communities
since it was started
in 2008 were either
convicted criminals
or foreigners who
had failed to obey a
court order to leave
the country or who
had returned to the
United States
illegally after
deportation.
Immigration
officials pointed to
the arrest in
January in Los
Angeles of a Mexican
man on charges of
driving with a
suspended license.
After a Secure
Communities match,
the police learned
that he had been
convicted of drug
trafficking and
burglary and
deported six times.
Another Mexican
arrested in Los
Angeles was found to
have been convicted
in the killing of a
child in 1997.
Mr. Morton said he
had created the
advisory task force,
which went to work
in June, to
recommend fixes that
would lower the
numbers of
deportations of
illegal immigrants
who did not have
criminal
convictions.
Also on Tuesday, the
American Immigration
Lawyers Association
published a report
that cast light on
how Secure
Communities and
other enforcement
programs have
stirred tensions in
immigrant
communities. The
association, which
includes 11,000
immigration lawyers,
polled its members
to see how many were
handling cases of
immigrants facing
deportation after
being stopped by
local police
officers for minor
offenses, like
traffic violations.
Gregory Chen,
director of advocacy
for the lawyers’
association, said
his office was
deluged with
responses.
“Department of
Homeland Security
practices have
ushered in a sea
change in who is
being deported, and
our attorneys have
literally been
flooded with people
coming in to their
offices who have
been picked up by
local police for
small time stuff,”
Mr. Chen said. The
report, which
presents a sample of
127 cases from 24
states, was the “the
tip of the iceberg,”
he said.
The lawyers’ report
includes the recent
case of an immigrant
in New Mexico
detained for
deportation after
the local police
questioned him about
burning leaves in
the front yard. A
woman in Minnesota
was held by federal
agents after the
traffic police
stopped her saying
she failed to signal
a right turn. An
immigrant facing
deportation from
Florida was a
passenger in a
vehicle pulled over
in a traffic stop;
the vehicle was
driven by his wife,
a United States
citizen.
In 87 cases, the
report found, the
illegal immigrants
facing deportation
had no criminal
history, and 79 of
them were close
relatives of
American citizens or
legal permanent
residents. Many had
lived for more than
a decade in the
United States.
“Fundamentally,
D.H.S. is saying one
thing but doing
another,” Mr. Chen
said, arguing that
the lawyers’
findings
contradicted figures
provided by
immigration
officials. He said
the agency, by
detaining large
numbers of
immigrants after
minor offenses, was
“distorting its own
mission of focusing
on public safety and
national security
risks.”
Eleanor Pelta, the
president of the
lawyers’
association, urged
Mr. Morton to
improve screening
procedures so that
arrests by local
police did not lead
automatically to
federal deportation.
Cecilia Muñoz, the
White House official
who oversees
immigration policy,
said Mr. Obama
strongly favored
Secure Communities
because he does not
have the option of
saying, “While I’m
waiting for Congress
to come forward, I
am not going to
bother to enforce
the law.”
The program is “the
best tool we have,”
she said, “to
enforce the law in
the best possible
way.”
Fear and frustration
about Secure
Communities spilled
over during the
hearing on Monday in
Los Angeles, one of
five organized by
the task force. One
speaker, Isaura
Garcia, 20, said she
had been reported to
immigration
authorities by the
Los Angeles police
after she called 911
when she was beaten
by her boyfriend.
The program drew
praise from a
representative of a
Los Angeles County
supervisor, Michael
D. Antonovich, a
Republican. But an
official from the
office of Mayor
Antonio R.
Villaraigosa, a
Democrat, echoed
immigrants’
criticisms.
Shouting erupted
after one citizen,
Julio Giron, yelled
from the crowd to
defend the program,
which he said was
needed because Mr.
Obama had failed to
secure the border.
Soon after, most of
the opponents, who
significantly
outnumbered the
supporters, marched
out, calling on the
task force to
resign.













